Keywords
Clear


main image
09 Nov 2010 | Our resident tow expert, Phil Lord, offers his top five trucks of the last 12 months.

Land Rover Discovery 4 3.0 TDV6
The Land Rover Discovery 4 is a promising tow tug just with its lanky wheelbase, short overhangs and heavy, stable chassis alone. Add its chest-thumping Jaguar-sourced 3.0L V6 twin-turbo diesel engine and it knocks hills into plains. While it is a stable platform with excellent performance, and not too bad at the bowser, either, some won’t like the fact that Land Rover don’t recommend use of a weight distribution hitch. Even when you’re not towing, the Disco is a thoughtfully packaged, roomy 4WD with excellent on- and offroad ability. Around town, though, you notice every centimetre of its girth.

SPECS
Power: 180kW at 4000rpm
Torque: 600Nm at 2000rpm
Tow capacity: 3500kg/350kg
Towing fuel consumption: 15.0L/100km


Ford Territory TX RWD
There have been few Australian cars that have got it as right as the Ford Territory. While the design is getting a little dated, its all-round competence and popularity in a fast changing market shows just how well sorted the Territory is. While the SY Mark II update we tested early this year is not a huge departure from the 2004 original, its slight design refresh and minor engine tweaks in the RWD version are worthy improvements. A stable tow vehicle, the Territory provides enough torque for easy cruising. While it isn’t super-economical when towing, without a van it can achieve less than 10L/100km on an easy cruise. The Territory is an affordable, roomy and well executed design that is still the dynamics benchmark in its class. With the introduction of a V6 turbo-diesel in time for a major refresh next year, it promises to be even better again.

SPECS
Max power: 190kW at 5250rpm
Max torque: 383Nm at 2500rpm
Tow capacity: 2300kg/230kg
Towing fuel consumption: 20.5L/100km


Toyota Prado Kakadu 3.0TD
Toyota just about owns the copyright for 4WD in Australia, and it’s no surprise that the latest Prado 150 Series is a further refinement of the super-successful nameplate. The top-shelf Prado Kakadu offers lush equipment levels, a cushioned ride and, when towing, a stable load hauler. While the 3.0L TD engine is a little thirsty, it keeps up a steady cruise when towing and is responsive around town without a van behind. The improved safety features and overall refinement over the 120 Series is great, but it’s the leap forward in offroad technology that makes this vehicle most interesting.

SPECS
Max power: 127kW at 3400rpm
Max torque: 410Nm at 1600rpm
Tow capacity: 2500kg/250kg
Towing fuel consumption: 15.2L/100km


Kia Sorento SLi 2.2TD
Regular CW readers will know we ran a long-term test Sorento for six months in 2008, and were impressed with the strong towing ability and good value rolled into a compact 4WD wagon. The all-new 2010 Sorento has lost weight and added space, power torque and a swag of refinement. Unfortunately, it has also shed 800kg off its towing capacity. So if you’re happy with a van on the lighter side of 2000kg, the Sorento should be on your shopping list for its outstanding engine torque, towing economy, comfortable interior and composed manners on the road.

SPECS
Max power: 145kW at 3800 rpm
Max torque: 436Nm at 1800-2500rpm
Tow capacity: 2000kg/150kg
Towing fuel consumption: 13.7L/100km


Holden Calais V Sportwagon 3.6 SIDI
While the VE Commodore has just changed to its series II update, the MY10 VE Calais V Sportwagon we tested this year, with the new direct-injection 3.6L V6, is no different mechanically. And otherwise, there are only styling tweaks and new features such as larger alloy wheels and a new central info screen. The ultra-smooth, powerful and torquey V6 is wrapped in a stylish, stable and comfortable towing platform. This is the closest Holden has been to challenging the Euro wagons – and beats them hands down as a tow vehicle.

SPECS
Max power: 210kW at 6400rpm
Max torque: 350Nm at 2900rpm
Tow capacity: 2100kg/210kg
Towing fuel consumption: 17.1L/100km

Comments (85)
Comment by Unknown
posted 4 months ago
Bought A 2010 Navara 2.5 t diesel auto dual cab . Towing 2.800 van 22 to the 100 fuel.Snaped a tail shaft at the rear uni joint . Nissan don't want to know me. Had to tow it home from the WA dealer and fit a 2hand one cost $150I have sold Nissans all my working life {now retired}Why has this product turned to crap. Peter Perth
Comment by Unknown
posted 6 months ago
Hi- I have had a 2004 CX8 for 8 years. I love it to pieces. Towed 2 horses and a float around Victoria. Averaged about 18 l per 100 k's. Had it serviced every 10,000kms. Done 363000 k's and going strong. Shame they didn't keep it going.Replaced parts? the air assisted shockers, a fuel pump, and the exhaust system. Fair wear and tear, really. LOVE IT , but as I am retiring out of the horse world, am selling it. I need a smaller SUV- that can tow at a pinch,( 1500kgs) .Looking at the v6 RAV LS whatever ....ANy ideas?
Comment by Unknown
posted 10 months ago
How do you determine what's the best to buy between diesel and petrol when you want to get a 4 x 4 for towing???? Confused
Comment by Unknown
posted 1 year ago
Have a look at the Caravan Magazines and you see the Nissan D40 STX. Where do you rate this Tow Vehicle?
Comment by Unknown
posted 1 year ago
Thinking of getting 19 to 21ft caravan , I have a standard 2010 Holden ss ute , can it do the job and I worry about it being thirsty , has anyone used one before , thanks r&r
Comment by Unknown
posted 1 year ago
discovery 4 all the way
Comment by Unknown
posted 1 year ago
Re: Nissan 3.0L Auto Patrol drive plate failure. Is this a common fault? I like the new more powerful engines of,say, the Ranger and mazda BT50 but are the parts (such as drive plates and gearboxes) made of heavy duty stuff to withstand the higher pressures and loads?
Comment by Unknown
posted 1 year ago
just don't try towing with a Mazda tribute - what a heap of crap!
Comment by Unknown
posted 1 year ago
WHERE IS THE DIESEL NT MITSUBISHI PAJERO???

YOU SEE A LOT OF THEM AT VAN PARKS AND ON THE ROAD!!
Comment by Unknown
posted 1 year ago
Why is the Commodor there instead of the Falcon. There is a significant different on torque and the rpm at which it is delivered between the two (in favour of the Falcon)
Comment by Unknown
posted 1 year ago
The 2012 F-150 SD Super Cab 4WD is available with efficient engine and has lots of powerful features. The exterior is stylish but the interior lacks in beauty and grace. The steering is a bit numb and stiff. http://www.joy2day.com/cars/ford/super-duty/ford-f-350-super-duty-4wd-2012.php
Comment by Unknown
posted 1 year ago
It would prove interesting to see how the kia sorento rear measures after 150 kgs are applied to tow bar, normal ball wt is 10% of towing capacity any one towing any readers have info much appreciated thanks
Comment by Unknown
posted 1 year ago
Hey wot about the Prius?

Just jokin' guys
Comment by Unknown
posted 1 year ago
should be rated in there capacity and price then watch the 3 ton class be taken out by mitsi and nissan
Comment by Unknown
posted 1 year ago
I can,t fault my Mitsubishi Triton 2.5 Diesel twin cab, have just completed 2 long trips this year, to Batemans Bay and Cooktown and did not miss a beat and economy was excellent.
Comment by Unknown
posted 1 year ago
nisson patrol 4500 on gas and petrol
Comment by Unknown
posted 1 year ago
There is an old saying; "Tis far better to sit quietly with your mouth closed and let people think you are an idiot, rather than open your mouth and let everyone kno0w you are an idiot."
Comment by Unknown
posted 1 year ago
Can't you people read, the reason your vehicle is not mentioned is because, " IT WASN'T MANUFACTURED IN THE LAST 12 MONTHS," read the colomn properly,
JG
Comment by Unknown
posted 1 year ago
why doesn't Kia or Hyundai have decent ball weights
Comment by Unknown
posted 1 year ago
When towing a heavy off road van you have a small choice off vehicle which will tow this, a twin cab ute new nissan? which will be working to its max, or a 200 series for the power, go the Toyota .
Comment by Unknown
posted 1 year ago
I have just watched and read all these reports on available tow rigs by these testing personnel.COME ON GUYS get with it ,you tell us what the vehicle can actually tow ,but towing a empty van is one thing ,but go a little further and and tow a fully loaded van as people would do it and see how it compares then .DO IT PROPERLY OR DONT WASTE YOUR TIME .S.EFFORD
Comment by Unknown
posted 1 year ago
Wheres the good old f truck great for goosenecks and other towing, reliable easy to fix/maintain very powerful even on gas.
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
I cannot understand how the Pajero diesel or petrol can be left out of this comparison I have been towing caravans and using 4WD'S since I was 18 years old and now I am 56 years old and on my 4th Pajero after having owned Landrovers and Toyotas.
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
What about the new Landcruiser 70 series ute. Does anyone have any comments about it? Need to pull 3
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
No problems with our nissan patrol 3lt TD. Chuggs along nicely with our 21ft 2100 van. Even through the hilly country. Fuel was on par with the others. Obviously changes with the terrain.
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
What about the Landcruiser 200 Series 4.5.td
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
I have a Disco 3 with 32,000ks and its on its 3rd injector pump & 2nd power steering unit. Its been on the back of a tow truck 4 times. When its going it is a top tow tug BUT it does not keep going. All services etc are done a Landrover dealers. Thanks leeoor
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
Thanks all you buggers for totally confusing me on buying a tow vehicle. I have decided not to risk using my new Camry and will invest in a second hand Pajero I think after reading your comments. Any advice would be appreciated. Mike. email: janmike70@westnet.com.au
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
I am interested in knowing if the new 2011 Freelander 2 makes good tow vehicle. Phil Lord, will you be doing a test on this anytime soon.
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
where's the ISUZU D MAX ?????? THIS IS N_O 1
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
any comments on mitsubishi triton 2.5 turbo diesel gl-r ute
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
I love my Mercedes Benz Vito Wagon 115CDI, has done a couple of major trips with 4,6 or 8 persons plus my Jayco 17.76 pop-top. Last trip from Sydney to Darwin then round the West Australian coast to Adelaide, before coming home via Mildura, the 2.2litre turbo diesel gave around 13litres per 100km with van in tow, and less than 11 over the bight with a big tail-wind. Economical and roomy.
Roger
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
Nissan has had overheating problems from the undersized 3.0L in the patrol, clutch problems in all their diesels, and major engine problems from spun bearings to compltete detonation.
The smaller SUV range has adopted the CVT transmission, the same as Chrysler(Jeep & dodge), leaving you with a powerless drive.
Nissan will not make any top 5 until the launch of the renault V6 diesel in late 2012.

Toyota & Nissan are only interested in breaking into the tight US market, opening factories in Texas. Colarado/D max are having a lot of problems being slapped together in Spain, Russia or Thailand. This has alerted Korean car manufacturers into filling the SUV market with some impressive vehicles, with the only Japanese competitor taking our maket seriously.....
Mitsubish!!
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
you all have no idea new discovery 4 hands down
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
Hi Bob, I've been unhappy with a previous tow vehicle, had a Subaru Outback 3.0R (2004) pulling our little Jayflight (1100kg ATM) and it was very poor, used 20L/100 km or more as you had to keep the revs up otherwise it went nowhere. Changed to a Ford BF XR8 with the same van and used only 16L/100km and could almost idle up ranges, also the heavier longer car was far more stable. I think many neglect the stability factor that a longer wheelbase adds.
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
I have Disco 4 3.0 TDV6 it does a fab job of towing my Sterling caravan with ATM 2700 kg, powerful, economical,safe, comfortable, great on the beach, I wouldn't swap it.
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
Is anyone NOT happy with their current Tow Tug? Cheers, Bob
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
I would like to know what they towed with the Territory. I tow a pop top Jayco with my Ford G6E Turbo, just did 8000km and averaged 15.5L/100km. This rig has so much power you can overtake 6cyl Commodores etc up hills / mountains. I test drove a diesel Pathfinder and even unloaded it was an absolute snail. The Ford turbo 6 has more power and pretty much more torque than any diesel over a much wider rev range.
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
I think you have got it wrong, the Pajero diesel should be in the top 5.
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
Wow, I have stirred the pot! Most if not all the vehicles you guys mentioned in comments above have not been released to the market as new vehicles in the last 12 months. That was the basis of the story - Caravan World has tested most of the vehicles you mentioned, but not in the last year, because they've been on the market (and tested by us) before that. As for the new vehicles that didn't make the cut, well that was because they simply were not as good as those that did. Thanks for all your input, and it's interesting to see the cross section of vehicles you are using as tow tugs.
Phil Lord.
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
You can add the kj jeep cherokee 2.8 diesel to that list. 2270/227
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
Towing capacity is lacking in most of the 5 vehicles shown unless you're just towing a camper trailer.
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
Like the Hilux, when they work out all their bugs, they may get on the list.
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
A wise mechanic once told me that you can't beat cubic capacity. This has been proved so many times........So where is the Cruiser?? Are you just toying with us ?? Small engines with high turbo boost are good for a short time. But has anybody done a test for longevity?? We love our tow tugs and want to keep them for a long time (for many reasons), but will the current crop of suped up turbos last the test of time?? Will manufacturers realize the balance of towing ability / trendy looks / and technology?? I don't know. Cheers Monty
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
I question the Land Rover Discovery 4 3.0 TDV6
choice. I had a Discovery for a number of years and found that the Western Australian distributor charges unbelivable high fees for service and spare parts and you had to go back time after time to get the job done properly. I am now onto my second Landcruiser, service fees are about 1/3, the job gets done first time properly and you can get parts anywhere. I guess that's why the mines all use them. And you harly know my Trailstar Caravan is on the back.
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
What about the 450 Nm 140Kw Pathfinder
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
can you give me some comment about nissan 3.0 ltr turbo diesel
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
Yes, I agree. We have a Pajero, bought new last year and we tow a 21ft 6 Traveller caravan, with tinnie on top of the car and the Pajero has never missed a beat. Very comfortable around town also. We get 15.3L/100 and 19-21L/100 with van behind. A great 4X4. Jan.
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
And what about the new Mitsubishi Challenger,at least it's a proper four wheel drive!
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
My VW Golf 2.0 TDI used 7.1L/100km on a recent 12,000km trip to Darwin towing an A'liner.
It is different in the UK, they include smaller vehicles with better fuel consumption in their awards.
The Škoda Superb Estate Elegance 2.0 TDI CR took the top honour in the 28th UK Caravan Club Towcar of the Year 2011 competition.
Other winners were:
* Škoda Fabia Elegance 1.6 TDI CR
* Fiat Doblo 2.0 MultiJet Eleganza
* Volkswagen Golf Match 2.0 TDI 140
* Mercedes-Benz E350 CDI BlueEfficiency
* Mitsubishi Outlander 2.2 DI-D Juro SST
* Range Rover Sport TDV6 HSE
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
try kia sorento manuel with 2400 kg on the back to give us an idea on how it goes
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
Funny that, Mitsubishi Pajero's never crack a mention. Our NP averages 14L/100km towing a van, better than 10L/100Km without a van with a tow capacity of 250kKg/250kg. Newer models have higher tow capacity. Me thinks the review lacks credibility.
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
have not seen too many of the top ;5; around the caravan park,s etc.popular??? i do not beleive so.
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
Why is it that the big two are not present in this test as it is only one with a three ton tow rate is in the list
Regards Chris
keep up the good work
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
Agreed, the Pajero, should be number 1, for the average of most caravans, apart from those over 3T. The diesel is exceptional as well as the petrol/LPG combo (bearing in mind the touring km's without a van once you reach a destination. Too many journos have big prejudices in favour of Toyota, & bearing in mind that the majority of grey nomads do not go off road.
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
What about the Landcruiser?
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
What about the Nissan X Trail
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
i totally agree the pajero is at least equall to the range rover and toyota
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
The Disco will win again.....as is has on every other test I have read, but not all of us can afford overpriced Landrovers.
Sorry Pajero should be No1!!!!:)
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
Agree with your comment totally
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
I can't fault our Challenger LS manual as a tow vehicle!
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
Mitsubishi Pajero, number 1 Mid size tow vehicle, according to Caravan and Motorhome on Tour and Best Medium Diesel Wagon And Best Value for money 2010 4WD Overlander magazine.
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
Where is the JEEP GRAND CHEROKEE, would pull the pants off all those clunckers. from noall2
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
What weight was the caravan that was being towed
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
he is right the pajero should be on the list
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
I agree the pajero is a great tower also
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
should try the pathfinder
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
What happened to the Patrol?
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
Agree with the above comment.
Mitsubishi is lighter on the pocket, heavier on the towing capacity (3000Kg)and better on fuel economy.
Are you really very objective on you testing or does it depend on the lunch provided.
GCraig
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
Nissan Patrol TD is missing also. Should be No. 1
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
Mitsubishi Triton 3.2d 5 speed manual should be top of the list!
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
Ford Ranger Trailmasta 3L an exceptional tow vehicle
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
Phil Lord has lost credibility by omitting the Mitsubishi Pajero and the Toyota Landcruiser 200 from any list of the best van tugs on the road in Australia. Stick a decent sized van on some of those he nominates and they would become traffic hazards. Ralphj585
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
The list could go indefinitely. We have a 2009 Hyundai Santa Fe diesel. Just back from 20000kms round Queensland. Overall consumption 12.5.Comfort and complete ease of towing.Jan, Echuca
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
the territory only has a 69 liter tank,so you would need to fill it every 5 minutes.so evey 350 kilos you need a bowser.
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
You show a mitsi towing then don't have it?
The better towing one was not allowed in?
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
Having driven and worked on all of the vehicles listed, I would still prefer my Landcruiser 200 Seriers to get me and my Kedron to where I want to go and then back home safely without any worries.
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
I agree whats the specs and report on the Pajero
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
20 Litres / 100km for the Territory, what a waste of time testing such a poor vehicle.
Where is the DiD Pajero ?
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
l have a jeep grand cherokee 2.7 td it pulls my 21 foot caravan with ease 90-100 up and down hills no problem l bet you never even tried it
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
I'll rope any one of these to my van and tow the lot easily with my Landcruiser.
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
Where is Subaru Forester, 327,000 km towing a small van and not one breakdown. Cruise Control at the speed limit and over most hills without kicking down at the crest. Just purched another for the next 400,000 Ks. Gordon Tullamarine
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
or the Nissan Patrol or any of the one ton utes in single or twin cab.3000kg /300 at 10l/100
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
And I think a Triton would be well placed for the same reasons
Comment by Unknown
posted 2 years ago
Where is the Mitsubishi Pajero. It should be number 2 on the list.

Add Comment
SUBMIT COMMENT